Comment by ben_w

Comment by ben_w 2 days ago

0 replies

> Is this even a trait of consciousness?

There's 40 or so different definitions of the word, so it depends which one you're using when you ask the question.

For me, and not just when it comes to machine minds, the meaning I find most interesting is qualia — unfortunately, I have no particular reason to think this hierarchy helps with that, because there might be a good evolutionary reason for us to have a subjective experience rather than mere unfeeling circuits of impulse and response, it's (1) not clear why this may have been selected for, and evolution does do things at random and only select for/against when they actually matter, and (2) it's not clear when in our evolution this may have happened, and (3) it's not clear how to test for it.