Comment by IAmBroom

Comment by IAmBroom 3 days ago

3 replies

I can provide more than just one example to back up any prejudice you can think of.

Treating a person as part of a group is the problem.

And when you are trying to isolate one person out of many, like for a job hire, it's not easy to avoid mass-filtering to speed it up.

sokoloff 3 days ago

> Treating a person as part of a group is the problem.

Yes, but it's efficient and effective in a large number of cases.

Those with no programming experience is a group. Those who just graduated a CS program is a group. Fresh bootcamp grads are a group. People with 5+ years of experience with your tech stack are a group.

Is there someone with no programming experience who would turn out to be great? Of course; none of us were born with programming experience, but most people are practical enough to not bat an eye when we use past experience as a proxy to quickly pre-filter the possible candidate pool.

  • IAmBroom 3 days ago

    Exactly true. But being hairless apes, we tend to overrely on our ability to group. "Smells like ___, must be bad at finding bananas in modern C++ product development process."

    Where ___ is: "no formal education", the accuracy is possibly over 50%.

    Where ___ is: "Dutch", the accuracy is below 50%

yieldcrv 3 days ago

There is tons of overfitting done by hiring managers