Comment by PaulDavisThe1st

Comment by PaulDavisThe1st 7 days ago

3 replies

View on Hacker News

> are the legislature and executive branches not independent?

I am not sure how this can be a serious question right now, in 2025.

However, in 2017 the capitulation of power and authority by Congress was less obvious. What was still true was that the Republicans who controlled Congress and the President all wanted a large tax cut for higher income Americans, and were thus aligned on the goal. Since the President doesn't actually write legislation, this alignment was all that was needed to push the bill through.

fuzztester 7 days ago

>I am not sure how this can be a serious question right now, in 2025.

it was a serious question.

I did know that the republicans are in the majority in both the lower and upper houses, after the recent US election.

but was not sure if that was the only factor involved.

I am not from the US. just an interested observer.

hence my question.

Reply View 2 replies
  • PaulDavisThe1st 7 days ago

    the two branches are theoretically independent. what is happening right now is that, depending in your POV:

    1) the Republican majority in both the house and senate are entirely on board with all of the Trump administration's actions, and thus have no reason to pass legislation or act in any way separately from the executive branch.

    2) the Republican majority in both the house and senate are craven and terrified of the MAGA base that Trump commands, and in many cases in the house, are very much connected to it, so much so that they will do nothing to stand up to the executive branch even when it has crossed lines that have not been crossed before in many different areas.

    Take your pick.

    Reply View 1 reply