Comment by 9d

Comment by 9d 8 days ago

5 replies

No, I do not accept this. There must be a way. What if the mirror box has a high enough heat? Would it work then? The box could be made of a heat resistant material, like fiberglass.

Bjartr 8 days ago

It's not that the mirror or box is damaged by heat, it's that each bit of heat energy comes from a bit of light energy. Eventually the light bounces enough times that there's no energy left in it.

  • 9d 7 days ago

    I understand, but what I mean is, what if there is no more opportunity for the light to emit heat, because the surrounding environment is already saturated with so much heat that it can't accept more? Is this a possible way to prevent the light from emitting heat and therefore prevent the light from decreasing its luminousness? There must be a way!

    • Bjartr 7 days ago

      Why must there be a way?

      A few notes: * There's no such thing as "absolute hot" state that meansno more heat can be added * Blackbody radiation means that above a certain temperature, regardless of what you make your mirror out of, it will be spontaneously emitting visible light at all times.

      • lukan 7 days ago

        Indeed. There is only an absolute zero, that cannot get colder, but more heat is always possible as more heat means more rapid movement of elements. While absolute zero at 0 K means no movement.

    • lukan 7 days ago

      Are you aware of that old concept and why it doesn't work?

      https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetuum_mobile

      Same principle.

      Basically, what you propose negates the nature of reality. There is always friction/energy loss into heat (increased chaotic movement). Only way to deal with it, if you want permanent cycles, is constantly add energy in the same amount that is lost.