Comment by brookst

Comment by brookst 2 months ago

4 replies

What percent of applications require that level of reliability?

Vibe coding will be normalized because the vast, vast majority of code is not life or death. That literally what “normal” means.

Exceptional cases like pacemakers and spaceflight will continue to be produced with rigor. Maybe even 1% of produced code will work that way!

codr7 2 months ago

Do we really want to go further down this path?

Things that used to work just fine are already breaking badly because of AI.

poulpy123 2 months ago

Not so many, but all programs need to be designed and developed with reason, not statistics

zzzeek 2 months ago

this is black and white thinking. if the practice of "let the AI write the code and assume it's fine because I'm only an incurious amateur anyway" becomes normalized, the tendency of AI to produce inaccurate slop will become more and more part of software we use every day and definitely will begin impacting functions that are more and more critical over time.

  • brookst 2 months ago

    Different tools for different jobs is not black and white thinking.

    I remember when people said the same thing about Basic; how dare anyone create such an abomination, whole generations of programmers will be useless because they learned this oversimplified, terrible language instead of proper assembly.

    We were fine.