Comment by TeMPOraL

Comment by TeMPOraL 14 hours ago

5 replies

Here's an underappreciated problem with biking in cities: storage. Most people in cities live above ground[0], and buildings don't have dedicated bike storage. Bike theft is common, and is a unique crime in being simultaneously highly disrupting to the victim, trivial to pull off, and not big enough monetarily for the police to bother pursuing - so you can't really park on the street overnight like you'd do with a car; it's too risky. This means people end up storing bikes in their apartments. Bikes are heavy and unwieldy and full of pointy bits and hard edges; going up and down with them is super annoying, especially if you don't have a lift (or it isn't big enough to fit a bike).

Solve the storage problem, and a lot more people city dwellers owning a bike will start using it daily, and many of those who don't will buy one.

--

[0] - Follows obviously from assuming most buildings have at least one floor.

mejutoco 14 hours ago

Foldable (brompton for example) bikes, and owning a shitty bike are common solutions to this problem.

  • TeMPOraL 13 hours ago

    Shitty bikes are just as heavy, if not more, than good bikes.

tokioyoyo 13 hours ago

All of this is just cultural cope. Bikes are stolen in Tokyo and Amsterdam as well. Tokyo space is incredibly limited. And etc.

The problem is, biking is just not efficient compared to other transport modes in super majority of the cities in NA. There is no political appetite either. People just love their cars, and can’t be bothered to restructure their lives like my friends in Paris did.

  • TeMPOraL 12 hours ago

    FWIW, I'm writing from perspective of someone who lives and lived most of their life in Kraków, Poland - a city and culture that never been bike-hostile, and is increasingly bike-friendly. Despite owning a bike, I haven't rode much in the city since my university years, precisely because of the hassle of storing it and bringing it up and down 2-4 floors without a lift. I don't drive, I use public transit, walk, or rent e-scooters - and the latter is inferior to your own bike in every way except it's there and you don't have to carry it up and down the stairs.