Comment by protocolture

Comment by protocolture 21 hours ago

3 replies

Good curation is amazing.

When I first signed on to Netflix it worked me out and suggested a bunch of stuff that I love to this day.

But then it ran out of stuff, or they borked the algorithm and now it sucks. And all its competitors suck.

One thing I have noticed is that if you ask a human for a specific recommendation like "Suggest me a novel like The Martian" if they dont have a specific recommendation, you just get their favourite instead. Which makes reddit threads and similar completely useless. The signal to noise ratio is awful.

9dev 16 hours ago

Actually with Netflix, I'd argue that they used to produce a few shows that were great, novel, and interesting to watch. But over time, as their revenue (and shareholder expectations) grew, they started to crunch out targeted content created for specific audiences at a budget (ever noticed how the set is practically empty save for the show's protagonists at all times?). These shows suck because they're not works of art, but metric-driven checklists of features that the target group enjoys.

I assume there's a small sliver of budget available for actually interesting productions, kind of similar to Google's moonshots, but the vast majority of Netflix' catalog is just algorithmic crap by now, so the recommendations are probably solid, there's just nothing good to recommend.

  • protocolture 15 hours ago

    The things I enjoyed that netflix curated for me all preexisted netflix. I bought in to netflix for the good content productions, but I stayed as long as I did for the recommendation engine.

robertlutece 17 hours ago

off topic, but I recently read Alfred Lansing's "Endurance" and felt that was in spirit like "The Martian" although I remember the latter more from the film than the book.