Comment by handzhiev

Comment by handzhiev a day ago

6 replies

No, because it's usually a few years old and already obsolete - the frameworks and the language have gone through a gazillion changes and what you did in 2021 suddenly no longer works at all.

moooo99 a day ago

I mean, the training data also has a cutoff date and changed beyond that are not reflected in the code suggestions.

Also, I know that people love to joke on modern software and JS in particular. But if you take react code from 2020 and drop it into a new react codebase it still works. Even class based components work. Yes, if you jumped on the newest framework bandwagon every time stuff will break all the time, but AI won’t be able to help you with that either. If you went for relatively stable frameworks, you can re use boilerplate completely or with relatively minimal adjustments

  • whstl a day ago

    React is alright but the framework tooling around it changes a lot.

    If you take a project from 2020 it's a bit of a pain to upgrade it.

  • scarface_74 17 hours ago

    True. But LLMs have access to the web. I’ve told ChatGPT plenty of times to verify an SDK API or if I knew the API was new, I just gave it a link to the documentation. This was mostly around various AWS SDKs

    • simonw 17 hours ago

      The search improvements to o3 and o4-mini have made a huge difference in the last couple of weeks.

      I ran this prompt (and others like it) and it actually worked!

        This code needs to be upgraded to the new
        recommended JavaScript library from
        Google. Figure out what that is and
        then look up enough documentation to
        port this code to it
      
      https://simonwillison.net/2025/Apr/18/gemini-image-segmentat...
asdff 14 hours ago

Ehh most people are good about at least throwing a warning before they break a legacy pattern. And you can also just use old versions of your tools. I'm sure the 2021 tool still does the job. Most people aren't working on the bleeding edge here. Old versions of numpy are fine.

jay_kyburz 20 hours ago

lol, I've been cutting and pasting from the same projects I started in 2010. When you work in vanilla js it doesn't change.