Comment by tptacek

Comment by tptacek 3 months ago

13 replies

I think most of the time when we tell ourselves this, it's cope. Software is automation. "Computers" used to be people! Literally, people.

myk9001 3 months ago

> "Computers" used to be people! Literally, people.

Not always. Recruitment budgets have limits, so it's a fixed number of employees either providing services to a larger number of customers thanks to software, or serving fewer customers or do so less often without the software.

  • tptacek 3 months ago
    • myk9001 3 months ago

      Thank you for the link, the reference you're making slipped past me. That said, I think my point still holds: software doesn't always have to displace workers, it can also help current employees scale their efforts when bringing on more people isn't possible.

      • kcexn 3 months ago

        While this definitely helps consumers. I don't see how it doesn't displace workers.

        If the work those workers were doing before software was truly valuable. Companies would find other ways to scale, and simply pass the higher costs onwards to consumers.

ToucanLoucan 3 months ago

I'm unable and unwilling to shadowbox with what you think I'm actually experiencing.

  • tptacek 3 months ago

    That's fine; read it as me speaking to the whole thread, not challenging you directly. Technology drives economic productivity; increasing economic productivity generally implies worker displacement. That workers come out ahead in the long run (they have in the past; it's obviously not a guarantee) is besides my point. Software is automating software development away, the same way it automated a huge percentage of (say) law firm billable hours away. We'd better be ready to suck it up!

    • myk9001 3 months ago

      > That workers come out ahead in the long run (they have in the past...)

      Would you mind naming a few instance of the workers coming out ahead?

      • tptacek 3 months ago

        Sure. Compare the quality of life of the Computers to that of any stably employed person today who owns a computer.