Comment by bmacho

Comment by bmacho 15 days ago

4 replies

A burning house is not "a pool".

In my country you can't watch a kid drowning in a pool* but you are not obligated to help anyone in a burning house, since that would put you in danger too. I assume it is the same ~everywhere in the world, including the US.

* assume rescuing would be fairly safe, you are a good swimmer, you have lifeguard education, the weather is nice and the kid is small. AFAIK rescuing drowning people is dangerous as they can pull you down.

mikepurvis 15 days ago

A drowning child is of fairly limited threat to an even halfway competent adult swimmer. Even at maximum panic/flailing, they just don't have the mass or strength to prevent you from at least treading water.

  • sdwr 15 days ago

    I'm a good swimmer, and 50 pounds of thrashing, scratching and climbing feels dangerous.

  • [removed] 14 days ago
    [deleted]