Comment by sevensor

Comment by sevensor a day ago

11 replies

I find the most productive political discussions are about history. Most people don’t know any history at all, so a willingness to discuss the reason we have the Third Amendment, or the lasting effects of King Leopold’s dominion in Africa, or the Peleponnesian War, makes for a good discussion, and the distance makes people less emotionally tied to their positions and more willing to accept nuance. If we find we disagree, this also gives us social cover to pretend the topic isn’t intensely relevant to the present day.

niemandhier 21 hours ago

Maybe the long peace within the US changed things, but in most countries and especially in Europe discussing history in a room with more than 2 nationalities is a good recipe to sow dissent.

  • sevensor 21 hours ago

    Good point. I live in the US and I wouldn’t start with the American civil war. Talk about other people’s history. I’ll trade you the American Civil War for the Franco Prussian War.

    • Spooky23 20 hours ago

      The American Civil War is a great place to start. You can very quickly assess where somebody’s head is at and move on quickly.

      • s1artibartfast 19 hours ago

        That depends on what your purpose is having a conversation is in the first place

DeathArrow a day ago

Also, present day politics is in many cases determined by history.

  • sevensor 21 hours ago

    Exactly! What makes history relevant is that we are still living in it.