Comment by gregschlom

Comment by gregschlom 2 days ago

9 replies

It’s a great project overall but MDF is a very poor choice for the base. It will get destroyed as soon as it gets wet. At minimum they should have used exterior grade plywood, and painted it

f1shy 2 days ago

I‘m pretty sure it‘s from a region in the wotld were weather is very presictable, typically good, and people go out woth kids only in nice days, because there are so many.

  • cess11 2 days ago

    Looks like rain in one of the videos and it'll suffer wear from vibrations as well.

    It's a nice, cheap material for prototyping on, and then you can base the cut of a piece of metal or plastic on it for a more permanent solution.

fifticon 2 days ago

OSB wood?

  • IshKebab 2 days ago

    OSB is not very nice either. Plywood is definitely the choice here.

    I think MDF will easily last until his kids don't fit in it though. I don't think he's going to use it in the rain.

    • ty6853 2 days ago

      Advantech OSB will outlast conventional plywood by a mile in the rain. I exposed it, flat (the worst way possible) as subfloor, to rains for 1+ year while building my house with only maybe 1mm of fiber degrading on the surface a few places. Many modern OSBs use hydrophobic glues impermeable to water.

      • IshKebab 2 days ago

        Maybe but it's basically made of splinters. Not something you want in a thing you have to touch!

      • datavirtue a day ago

        That's what I was thinking. Plywood is a horrible choice.

    • woleium 2 days ago

      Marine ply would be my choice

      • BizarroLand a day ago

        If it were going to be exposed to the elements, I would pick a pine and waterseal it or a marine ply and waterseal it.

        It would fail eventually anyway, but either of those two options, depending on price, would be good and cheap enough to last.