Comment by neonsunset

Comment by neonsunset 3 days ago

As sibling comment pointed out, it's just .fsproj manifest and Program.fs file. What boilerplate do you speak of? It's on the opposite end boilerplate-wise to projects made in e.g. Java or TypeScript.

For F#, projects are needed to make full applications or libraries. Otherwise, you can simply write F# scripts with .fsx and execute them via 'dotnet fsi {SomeScript.fsx}'.

(obviously you can also specify dotnet fsi as shebang and integrate these scripts into general scripting on Unix systems - it's very productive)

twodave 3 days ago

I suspect they were either referring to pre-.NET Core days before the new project formats came out or they're creating projects in Visual Studio and checking all the optional boxes. There indeed did used to be a lot more required boilerplate to get some code running. Now you can run a .NET project quite nicely in VS Code with 2 total files.

Reply View 2 replies

shortrounddev2 3 days ago

Well also if you're using Visual Studio it will generate solution files as well, not just fsproj. I grew up doing C/C++ so boilerplate project/IDE/make files as well as build objects are something I expect to see. I think people who work in primarily JIT'd/interpreted languages are used to just having a directory tree full of source files and having some CLI tool manage everything for them. Maybe a dependency list file as well, but that's about it. Python is like this, and javascript CAN be like this

Reply View | 1 reply
- twodave a day ago
  
  Yeah, overall I agree. And I honestly can't imagine anyone who works with any popular javascript framework would flinch at the addition of a .sln file or /Properties folder lol...
  
  Reply View | 0 replies