Comment by DiggyJohnson

Comment by DiggyJohnson 2 days ago

10 replies

The president is in charge of executing the law. It’s in our system of checks and balances. I’m choosing to speak at an extremely general level, of course, but that is the answer to your question.

diggan 2 days ago

Specifically, I think it's "take care that the laws be faithfully executed" (Art. II, §3).

Does that mean "If foreign companies don't like our laws, they can pay to have them adjusted"? Seems not very faithful, but I hardly understand that word anymore it feels like.

  • DiggyJohnson 2 days ago

    From your second line, the answer is mostly no. Why are you assuming otherwise? Who is paying what to who?

    • DiggyJohnson 15 hours ago

      Edit for anyone confused:

      GP comment changed significantly (for the better).

  • krapp 2 days ago

    It means whatever SCOTUS decides it means, unless and until they decide otherwise.

    • nottorp 2 days ago

      So can Trump legally ignore this SCOTUS or not? :)

      • ImJamal 2 days ago

        The president can just not enforce a law.

      • krapp 2 days ago

        I mean, SCOTUS also decided nothing a sitting President does in their official capacity while in office can be considered a crime even if it breaks the law so yeah.

        • colejohnson66 2 days ago

          The logic behind such a ruling is nonsensical. Imagine if a president, in his/her official capacity, started murdering political rivals. In other countries, that's considered a dictatorship and should be stopped. But in America, that's completely legal according to SCOTUS. In fact, that was one of the questions asked by the justices!

          Apparently, committing crimes with absolute immunity is a necessary part of the presidential office. Without such protections, they'd be afraid to do things like extrajudicial drone strikes (Obama) and internment camps (FDR). Oh, wait.

          I hate to "Poe's Law" this tangent, but most people forget that Hitler's rise to power was also completely legal. Just change the constitution and get the judiciary to side with you, and you can do anything. It's terrifying.