Comment by krick

Comment by krick a day ago

8 replies

I feel like it should be updated. When it was written it wasn't like every Musk could launch high-orbit rockets on sundays. Only actual states did.

dragonwriter a day ago

The convention does not prevent national law from providing private liability which may come into play between entities subject to the jurisdiction of the same state or between the state who is liable to other states under the convention and entities operating within the state. So, there is no need to update the convention; the states from which private launches operate simply need adequate domestic law to cover both fully-internal liability and private launcher liability for claims against the government under the convention. (And the US generally does, with the basic regulatory regime being adopted and the private space launch industry operating in the 1980s; it is not an issue that arose with Musk/SpaceX.)

ceejayoz a day ago

States can set whatever rules they like internally. The US can make SpaceX pay them back if they want.

  • dylan604 a day ago

    [flagged]

    • dragonwriter a day ago

      The President has very little case-by-case authority over civil liability between private parties.

      I suppose Trump could advocate that Congress pass a new liability regime more favorable to SpaceX speciically or private launchers generally, though.

      • dylan604 a day ago

        Time and time again, we have seen GOP congress critters kowtow to Trump even before he won the election. You think any of them are going to suddenly grow a backbone and stand up to him now? You think if Musk picks up the phone and starts "asking" people they will push back?

tcmart14 13 hours ago

No expert, but I would assume, the USA would front it, but then take a case against SpaceX. So it would be Boat Owner v. USA, then USA v. SpaceX shortly after. Although I could be totally wrong.

But yea, seems appropriate to update it or if that is going to be the process, write it in stone.

oskarkk a day ago

Every rocket flight has to be approved by the government. No launch until FAA (and also FCC) OK's it.