scoofy 2 days ago

Eraserhead is borderline unwatchable. I love David Lynch, sort of, but without telling people that they're about to sit down and watch an hour-and-a-half of what is effectively an unwatchable piece of avant-garde cinema, then they're not going to be able to appreciate it.

There is nothing worse than getting excited to see a famous director's debut film, thinking you're going to have a good time, and then getting Eraserhead.

  • monophonica a day ago

    If someone is not into art films, to not start with Twin Peaks is absolutely insane to me.

    First two seasons of Twin Peaks are his masterpiece IMO and his most watchable.

    Those are some of the best characters of any film/tv show ever.

    From there I would go to Lost Highway next for a stronger dose of the more out there stuff.

    • ascagnel_ 17 hours ago

      Just start with the pilot first -- as it is, the US pilot is basically a feature-length film (it runs 1h25m), and features enough of Lynch's trademark juxtaposition of horrible and mundane, and piles on the warmth and love for his characters that set his works apart. The European cut of the pilot adds a few minutes to the end and originally aired as a TV movie, and may be worth it if you're not otherwise hooked by the show, since it features a definitive ending as well as the first appearance of the show's trademark "red room" (footage from the sequence was included in a later episode in the US).

      For me, the second step would either be The Elephant Man or Mulholland Dr. -- many of his works tackle very dark subject matter and include sexualized violence that can be downright disturbing to watch, but those two omit those elements. The Straight Story is much lighter, but largely lacks the surrealism Lynch is known for.

    • darthrupert 3 hours ago

      Most of second season of TP wasn't really Lynch.

    • 4ggr0 a day ago

      i tried watching Twin Peaks but my GenZ attention-hungy brain got really bored during the first episode. maybe i should give it another shot...

      it's not like i'm not used to watching long movies and i would call myself some form of cinephile, but for some reason Twin Peaks felt unbelievably slow.

      • wellthisisgreat 19 hours ago

        Twin peaks is incredible and Agent Cooper is a kind of a role model haha, never seen any other character like him

    • tpm a day ago

      But he didn't direct all of Twin Peaks episodes and it shows.

  • tjakab 2 days ago

    Eraserhead is highly watchable, but the first time you see it, it's best to just experience it without trying to process it too much. The nuance comes through on repeat viewings.

    • scoofy 2 days ago

      >Eraserhead is highly watchable

      It is a film explicitly designed to be unpleasant. This may be artistically interesting, but it's certainly no going to appeal to most people.

  • labster 2 days ago

    I rented Eraserhead and watched with some friends in college. I loved it, and so did the other Lynch fan. The other two, well, the first words spoken over the credits were “What the actual fuck was that?” Let’s just say it’s a divisive film.

kingstoned 2 days ago

    When people say "surreal" they mean "real", it's just most of your life is not very real, just repetition and routine. - Norm Macdonald
jimbob45 2 days ago

Dune or Twin Peaks are probably going to be more accessible than anything else.

For Eraserhead, I understand the metaphor of how parenting can be larger-than-life and terrifying and I see how Eraserhead was trying to embody that but I very much didn't appreciate the highly pessimistic ending. It's an early movie that would have benefited immensely from an alternate ending on its DVD.

  • Trasmatta 2 days ago

    I think there's a lot more to Eraserhead than that! I also don't really see the ending as pessimistic personally.

    Lynch: "Believe it or not, Eraserhead is my most spiritual film."

    Lean: "Elaborate on that?"

    Lynch: "No, I wont. No one sees it."

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjoMEw2RYlA

  • msabalau 2 days ago

    The Straight Story is almost certainly his most accessible film, while also very focused on themes that he cares about.

    It isn't the elusive puzzle that many cinephiles value in his work, but it is clearly a Lynch film, even if it's not a stereotypical one.

  • saijanai a day ago

    His most mainstream work is The Elephant Man, commissioned by Mel Brooks.

    • colmmacc a day ago

      The Elephant Man is great, but does have a surreal sequence, and is entirely in black and white. I'd vote for the The Straight Story, which is literally a Disney movie, being more mainstream.

  • gordon_freeman 2 days ago

    The beauty of Lynch films is that everyone can interpret it in their own way!

    • DrillShopper 2 days ago

      I know what you're trying to say, but that's also true of every other movie.

      • JKCalhoun a day ago

        Well Lynch famously said this over and over about his films — that they mean whatever people think they mean.

        Watch a few interviews where he is asked what a film of his means. A smirk comes on his face and he repeats his mantra.

        He never let on.

      • HKH2 a day ago

        No, there's far more room for interpretation than in a typical movie.

epolanski 2 days ago

Season 3 Twin Peaks is peak "I don't know what am I looking at".

  • Lio 2 days ago

    When it first came out I was so desperate to see it I watched the first episode twice without realising.

    I spent the whole time trying to work out what was different between the "two".

    I mean, it’s exactly the sort of thing he would do and I still loved it.

    Magic!

  • ruthmarx a day ago

    It's at least a third watching one of Kyle MacLachlan's characters walking around with brain damage.

    I liked the season after a rewatch but the Dougie stuff is still tedious.

    • MisterTea a day ago

      The Dougie stuff was silly fun. Cherry pie

      • ruthmarx 17 hours ago

        It wasn't particularly entertaining and was well overdone.