the-smug-c-one 2 days ago

What modern OS doesn't have the equivalent of mmap? Just som #ifdefs. I didn't know I'd ever hear "use malloc, because it's portable".

sylware is pretty much right anyway. Try to avoid malloc, or write smaller allocators on top of malloc.

  • pjmlp 2 days ago

    Why bother with some #ifdefs when the ISO C standard library already does the job?

    • the-smug-c-one 2 days ago

      Because you're probably writing a much larger program so some ifdefs aren't a big deal :-).

      • keyle 2 days ago

        This is a silly argument because at the end of the day, once you make your code portable, you've now duplicated 99% of malloc and free, and you've left a mess for the team or next guy to maintain on top of everything else. You've successfully lowered the abstraction floor which is already pretty low in C.

        • sylware 2 hours ago

          what?? The whole point is to create independence, then create "real-life" alternatives. I don't understand your point.