Comment by hakonjdjohnsen

Comment by hakonjdjohnsen 2 days ago

10 replies

This, very much this!

I do research in a subfield of optics called nonimaging optics (optics for energy transfer, e.g. solar concentrators or lighting systems). We typically use these optical design applications, and your observations are absolutely correct. Make some optical design software that uses GPUs for raytracing, reverse-mode autodiff for optimization, sprinkle in some other modern techniques you may blow these older tools out of the water.

I am hoping to be able to get some projects going in this direction (feel free to reach out if anyone are interested).

PS: I help organize an academic conference my subfield of optics. We run a design competition this year [1,2]. Would be super cool if someone submits a design that they made by drawing inspiration from modern computer graphics tools (maybe using Mitsuba 3, by one of the authors of this book?), instead of using our classical applications in the field.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42609892

[2] https://nonimaging-conference.org/competition-2025/upload/

bradrn a day ago

> I am hoping to be able to get some projects going in this direction (feel free to reach out if anyone are interested).

This does sound interesting! I’ve just finished a Masters degree, also in non-imaging optics (in my case oceanographic lidar systems). I have experience in raytracing for optical simulation, though not quite in the same sense as optical design software. How should I contact you to learn more?

accurrent a day ago
  • hakonjdjohnsen a day ago

    Yes, exactly. I have not looked at Mitsuba 2, but Mitsuba 3 is absolutely along these lines. It is just starting to be picked up by some of the nonimaging/illumination community, e.g. there was a paper last year from Aurele Adam's group at TU Delft where they used it for optimizing a "magic window" [1]. Some tradeoffs and constraints are a bit different when doing optical design versus doing (inverse) rendering, but it definitely shows what is possible.

    [1] https://doi.org/10.1364/OE.515422

    • roflmaostc a day ago

      Shameless plug, we use Mitsuba 3/Dr.JIT for image optimization around volumetric 3D printing https://github.com/rgl-epfl/drtvam

      • pjmlp 20 hours ago

        It looks quite interesting, especially the part of scripting everything in Python with a JIT, instead of the traditional having to do everything in either C or C++.

        Looking forward to some weekend paper reading.

      • hakonjdjohnsen a day ago

        Looks really cool! I look forward to reading your paper. Do you know if a recording of the talk is/will be posted somewhere?

        • roflmaostc 16 hours ago

          We presented this work at SIGGRAPH ASIA 2024. But I think they do not record it?

          Maybe in some time we also do an online workshop about it.

    • accurrent a day ago

      I dont know much about Optical engineering, but this sounds super exciting. I think I meant to point to mitsuba 3, not 2.