Comment by the__alchemist

Comment by the__alchemist 2 days ago

0 replies

>NOTICE THERE IS NO QUANTUM PHYSICS IN THIS DISCUSSION! The short range of the field is a “classical” effect; i.e., it can be understood without any knowledge of the underlying role of quantum physics in our universe. It arises straightforwardly from ordinary field concepts and an ordinary differential equation. Nothing uncertain about it.

It's interesting to me how fuzzy the definition of quantum physics is. For example, I've seen the description of particles as described by a wave function (e.g. electron position and momentum in an atom) labeled as a quantum phenomenon, but have also heard it, as in this quote, as classical, since it's defined by a differential equation; a "classical" wave. In that view, quantum only enters the model when modelling exchange effects, spin, fermion states etc.

With the former definition, as in the article, you see descriptions of the wave nature of matter, replete with Planck's constant, complex wave function representations etc described as classical.