Comment by nijave

Comment by nijave 4 days ago

1 reply

Even then (in my experience) it's pretty common to setup an email based account and it will auto link to an oauth one that already exists. Even if Google revoked oauth, many platforms let you use the email directly to login

ajross 4 days ago

Yes, but that's not a bug with Google OAuth. If Taskrabbit (in the example) decides to trust dankstartup.com emails as a root of trust for identity even though the business failed, that's on them[1], and certainly nothing Google can have prevented.

The contention in the article is that dankstartup.com's new owners can leverage their control of the domain to get access to existing OAuth-based sessions that will look to the service providers as if Google has authenticated the account holder.

[1] And just to repeat: that risk is precisely why serious businesses (Vanguard in the example) don't allow obscure email domains as authentication anymore.