Comment by mmooss

Comment by mmooss 8 days ago

9 replies

There are many problems, but that's not evidence that Mozilla's programs are ineffective. People have many health problems and diseases, but that doesn't mean the healthcare system in ineffective. What it shows is that we need Mozilla and healthcare.

> We're back to a browser monoculture, Chrome, and Google controls browsers

Don't forget Apple's browsers, including all the iPhone users.

stackghost 8 days ago

>People have many health problems and diseases, but that doesn't mean the healthcare system in ineffective.

This is a deeply flawed analogy, and the two situations are superficially similar at best.

  • mmooss 8 days ago

    Unless you share your reasoning, it's just a baseless claim. Also, what about the issue, whether or not you happen to like the analogy?

    • stackghost 8 days ago

      HN is a very poor medium for this type of conversation, so I'm just going to move on

      • mmooss 8 days ago

        What is the motivation for saying these things? You aren't the only one - lots of people on HN do it, especially today for some reason. It's some sort of rhetorical game or social activity, but I don't quite understand it. I'm genuinely trying to understand.

        • stackghost 7 days ago

          HN is just not a very good platform for discussions that go more than 4-5 replies.

          The UI is just poorly suited for protracted discussions, to the point that I'm not interested in continuing this comment chain.

JohnFen 7 days ago

> What it shows is that we need Mozilla and healthcare.

I agree, although I'd say that we need a mozilla-like effort that is effective.

> Don't forget Apple's browsers, including all the iPhone users.

Sure, but Apple's world is effectively a monoculture itself. If you don't buy into Apple and their ecosystem, the existence of those things is irrelevant.

  • mmooss 7 days ago

    > Sure, but Apple's world is effectively a monoculture itself. If you don't buy into Apple and their ecosystem, the existence of those things is irrelevant.

    Not in this context: Someone claimed above that the web browser market was a monoculture of only Google Chrome. Apple browsers has a large market share, so it's not a monoculture.

    • JohnFen 6 days ago

      By that I mean is that in order to use Apple's software, you have to join Apple's entire ecosystem. That means it's not really an alternative if you otherwise find Apple's products unacceptable.

      • mmooss 4 days ago

        You can use iPhones without using any other Apple products.