Comment by ssl-3

Comment by ssl-3 10 months ago

3 replies

It's not nonsense, though. It's just a generalization.

Here's another generalization: A car typically weighs between 1 and 3 tons, and typically travels on the highway between at speeds between 50 and 80MPH.

This generalization misses (many!) rather common outliers, and that's OK since it not meant to be particularly precise. That's the way of generalizations: They're generalized.

Meanwhile, please take a moment to read this: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

kragen 10 months ago

yes, i agree that it's reasonable to talk about the typical weight of cars. that is because they vary over many fewer orders of magnitude than the weights of objects made out of atoms or the bandwidths of submillimeter-wave signals, so it makes sense to talk about 'outliers' and edge cases such as golf carts and tanks. by contrast, there is no sense in which that is true of the bandwidths of submillimeter-wave signals, in part because they are mostly not of human origin, so your implied analogy is invalid

but, as i explained, that's not the only dimension along which the statement is nonsense; millimeter waves also don't deliver any hertz of bandwidth. it's a really multifaceted gem of cluelessness

the implication of the last line of your comment seems to be that you think i am not familiar with the site's guidelines, but it is unclear why. perhaps you think criticism of the ieee's editorial and human resources choices runs counter to the guidelines? perhaps you think there is nothing to be learned from my criticism? you'll have to be more specific if you want to have a substantive conversation

  • ssl-3 10 months ago

    I think that your directly-insulting attitude is undeserved, unnecessary, and that it is also counter to the general good.

    I have nothing further to discuss.

    • kragen 10 months ago

      my criticism of the ieee is deserved, necessary, in the public interest, and, furthermore, substantial and informative. why does it bother you? is your sister editor of ieee spectrum or something? obviously you're not tim hornyak because if you'd graduated from journalism school you'd be in favor of robust, substantial criticisms of public institutions like the ieee when they're failing society like this, and you're not an electrical engineer either