Comment by bluehatbrit

Comment by bluehatbrit 10 months ago

6 replies

That's really interesting, I personally don't read those tone differences based on the casing. Neither approach carries different warmth or formality to me at all.

I wonder if this is a regional or generational thing?

latexr 10 months ago

> I wonder if this is a regional or generational thing?

Generational is a good bet:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41537994

  • Wingy 10 months ago

    It's definitely primarily generational. In my experience, capitalization-as-tone is used by many Generation Z people. On the other hand, it is not widely used by older generations, or the younger Generation Alpha.

PKop 10 months ago

[flagged]

  • Wingy 10 months ago

    In my experience, that isn't the case. Among people who "have gotten used to" it, using capitalization to indicate the formality and/or tone of your message allows the reader to understand the writer's intention better. I have not observed any correlation between political leanings and this.

  • qubitcoder 10 months ago

    That seems dubious. Consider the "stylistic choices" of the former president in social media posts.

    • PKop 10 months ago

      I'm not sure what you dispute or your point is here. If people slightly or strongly start aping Trump's writing style in various forms I'd say there's a good chance those people are right wing or simply "not the same people writing in all lowercase" you know?

      You highlight stylistic choices. I'd say we can observe the differences in different styles and see how uses them. Is Trump writing in all lowercase? No. Is this poster writing like Trump? No. Do a lot of left-wing people use the all-lowercase style? I see it all the time, yes.