Comment by Filligree

Comment by Filligree 10 months ago

2 replies

Delivery is what happens when the signals cross from the wire into the network interface card.

Depending on the layer you’re operating on, you might instead say it’s the call to recv, or the DMA transfer. The point is that it’s logically a memcpy with no further processing. Just a memcpy. The physical data transfer.

It’s easy to build a reliable message-passing system on top of that, but any such system will either involve further processing or else be vulnerable to data loss.

lisper 10 months ago

> Delivery is what happens when the signals cross from the wire into the network interface card.

If you look at this sibling comment [1] you will find someone who disagrees with your definition.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41601562

On your definition, yes, exactly-once delivery is not possible. But I think your definition is neither reasonable nor authoritative.

  • srkiNZ 10 months ago

    FWIW, I consider that definition to be both reasonable and (in the context of "distributed systems") authoritative.