Comment by defrost
Which parágrafos or incisos of the Constituição da República Federativa do Brasil
> literally contains the words:
cited in English?
Isn't political debate in Brazil sharply divided by selective absolute Constitionalism in any case?
Why leap to the defence of bad faith falsehoods spread by bad losers of a democratic election?
Brazil is a Portuguese-speaking country. Obviously, the brazilian constitution is not written in English. I took the liberty of translating the passage so that people from this community would understand it.
You don't have to believe my translation. Here's a completely independent source I found by searching the web:
https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Brazil_2017
I will cite and copy the relevant parts from it.
The terms referenced by the above paragraph: It's really not that hard to read and understand these words. Surely you'll agree that there is not a single case here that says these judges get to censor anyone for any reason at all. If a brazilian is harmed by speech, he gets to answer and to be made whole by compensation, financial or otherwise. He does not get to censor the other guy. I simply cannot find in this entire text a single exception that would allow censorship.Debating these points here on HN, I've had people cite lesser laws than the constitution, I've had people get into incredibly pedantic arguments over how it's ackshually not really censorship when you delete the political opposition's social media, I've had people appeal to authority, I've had people call me a moron. I've never, not once, had them point out to me where in the fuck it says, in the above text, that these judges can do what they're doing.
> Isn't political debate in Brazil sharply divided by selective absolute Constitionalism in any case?
The whole point of my comments is that everything in this country is like that. Even the supreme court judges, whose literal job is to interpret and apply the constitution, are like that. They "selectively and creatively interpret" the constitution.
This country has no laws. Only the whims of these judges.