Comment by Onavo

Comment by Onavo 10 months ago

4 replies

Then instead of regulating the companies, make SSN easily revokable and unique per service. I don't understand why Americans are so oppposed to a national ID despite the fact that every KYC service use SSNs and driver licenses.

mapt 10 months ago

The expansion of KYC and the hegemonic dominance of our global financial intelligence network is a recent infringement on our privacy that would not necessarily pass popular muster if it became well-known.

Most of our population is still living in a headspace where transactions are effectively private and untraceable, from the cash era, and has not considered all the ways that the end of this system makes them potential prey.

The fact is that the market is demanding a way to identify you both publicly and privately, and it will use whatever it needs to, including something fragile like a telephone number 2fa where you have no recourse when something goes wrong. It's already got a covert file on you a mile long, far more detailed than anything the intelligence agencies have bothered putting together. The political manifestation of anti-ID libertarians is wildly off base.

  • monksy 10 months ago

    The concern about organizations and the governments feelings that it needs to track you is a very valid concern. Why does the government need to make sure your "hand job from a friend" venmo payment to your friend is "legally legit"? (You can get transactions flagged for this and the moderator will shame you)

    Are you correct in what's going on? Yes. Are we placed in this with no option to resist? For the most part yes.

candiddevmike 10 months ago

Because they're the mark of the beast or a step towards fascism or something.

I don't think it would take much to convert real IDs into a national ID, they are as close to as they can get without "freaking people out".

  • Nevermark 10 months ago

    Emphasizing that the number can be changed would really help there.

    People could even generate their own number (private key), which they never gave out, and appeared differently to each account manager verifying it, and still replace them.

    When you choose your own number, it's only the Mark of the Beast if you are the Beast! * **

    * 666, 13, 69 and 5318008 expressly prohibited.

    ** Our offices only provide temporary tattoos.