Comment by dguest

Comment by dguest 10 months ago

6 replies

This surprised me:

    ...the rock era unfolded as ... a series of begats (Elvis begat the Beatles, the Beatles begat Jann Wenner, etc.) involving identity-famished teenagers and their heroes ... Cohen is absent from this narrative for one simple reason: He was the same age as Elvis.
I had to look this up: Actually he was a few months older (born in 1934 while Elvis was 1935).
allturtles 10 months ago

This seems to overlook the more obvious reason he is absent from that narrative: he was never all that popular. His only top 100 hit, for "Hallelujah", came in 2016, after his death.[0]

[0]: https://www.billboard.com/artist/leonard-cohen/; compare to Elvis https://www.billboard.com/artist/elvis-presley/, Beatles https://www.billboard.com/artist/the-beatles/

  • vjerancrnjak 10 months ago

    Yep, the album Various Positions on which Hallelujah appeared was not even released in the US by Columbia, they released it in Europe instead.

    I think it was only after Bob Dylan covered Hallelujah ~1988 at one of his live concerts, he was the first to cover it (John Cale did it in 1991), that the song and the album exploded in popularity.

  • [removed] 10 months ago
    [deleted]
  • fitsumbelay 10 months ago

    it's safe to say he was always a cult favorite at least since the mid-90s when I first heard of him. Mainstream writers of all sorts (music press among others) have certainly been writing about him for as long, for the same set of reasons he's being written about here

dennis_jeeves2 10 months ago

>involving identity-famished teenagers

Transposed to HN it would be:

The era of software unfolded as a series of frameworks, involving identity-famished nerds and their languages...