Comment by alasdair_

Comment by alasdair_ a day ago

3 replies

>The answer is less than 0.14%.

Is this per circuit? So if someone switches circuits every X hours, the chance of being caught after a year is actually quite high?

And even catching 0.14% of pedophiles would probably be worth it to the FBI or whatever, nevermind Iran catching dissidents or whatever.

My point is that is seems very cheap to do this (I as a random staff engineer could do it myself) and catch some people. A nation state could easily catch a much higher percentage if they increased the number of logging nodes slowly and carefully and deliberately did things like use many isps and update the servers gradually etc.

whimsicalism a day ago

The happy equilibrium is that if you have enough adversary nation-state intelligence services doing this and not sharing information, they'll cancel each other out and provide free node hosting.

qwery a day ago

You're misusing probability and ignoring critical information.

There's 1000 red marbles added to a jar with 8000 blue marbles (9000 total). Take three marbles from the jar randomly, one at a time. The odds of getting three red marbles is ~0.14%. That's all.

Tor nodes are not randomly picked marbles. The Tor network is not a jar.

  • whimsicalism a day ago

    they’re using probability correctly. if you have a critique state it clearly