crystal_revenge 2 days ago

Social media used to be about content sharing, but it's clear that it's far more profitable to keep your users on your site at all times and keep the content they create in house rather than linked somewhere else.

HN is probably the last true aggregator site left that I know of.

It's partly why the web is so much worse. There's really no reason to create content outside of a walled platform is it is getting increasingly difficult to find an audience for it. Even blogging is an uphill battle since more and more social media sites penalize link sharing (they want you to create the content on their platform and leave it there).

That's why it's not surprising that these APIs are disappearing since the fundamental model has changed.

pavlov 2 days ago

But that's too sensible and user-friendly. It would be obviously weird and wrong if they inserted ads and Musk's tweets into someone's RSS feed. Yet showing those unwanted insertions is the whole purpose of the company now.

  • sunaookami 2 days ago

    Twitter shut off RSS access over 10 years ago along with their popular 1.1 API.

    • pavlov 2 days ago

      I know. Because it wasn’t compatible with their aim of showing ads.

      And nothing has changed after Twitter went private under Musk, except that the reasons for stuffing unwanted content into users’ timelines are slightly different.

      • xNeil 2 days ago

        I don't think that's fair - getting back the chronological timeline itself made the purchase a good one in my eyes, alongside the For You feed, which seems to work wonderfully (for me). Not to forget you can literally turn off ads if you want. I seem to be a real minority, but I do genuinely believe Musk has done a great job with Twitter (or X).

spondylosaurus 2 days ago

You could get SMS notifications whenever a user tweeted, too. Imagine signing up for that today!

  • WorldMaker 2 days ago

    You could also for a long time send SMS (if you registered your number) to 40404 to tweet to Twitter. It's still in my address book from the era when I was tweeting T9 from dumb phones or using voice-to-SMS to tweet on early smart phones.