Comment by kergonath

Comment by kergonath 2 days ago

2 replies

> It's actually a pretty common law to have in some form to penalize tax evasion and capital flight.

It really does not sound common at all. In all countries where I have lived, my citizenship did not enter the picture for the local tax authority or that of my country of birth. All that matters is my resident status. I did not renounce any citizenship (because why would I? It comes with no downsides), but I cannot see them going after my foreign possessions, considering they entirely ignored them for years. And if they did, a loophole would be to not renounce it because again it comes with no downsides.

I actually checked with my country of birth, and renouncing simply requires me to send a declaration to the authorities and they have 2 months to accept (it’s accepted by default if they do not reply within 2 months). No other requirements or anything.

Do you have many examples of countries that do what you described?

dathinab 2 days ago

pretty much every EU country has a similar law

they do often work slightly different based fundamental differences in tax and law models so it's not always coupled to citizenship but practice still quite the same as in you get taxed when moving "capital" (mainly companies) out of the country

  • kergonath 2 days ago

    "pretty much every EU country" is not an example, so I guess no, then.

    Anyway, this is not what was discussed here, and has nothing to do with citizenship. The example was a non-resident's business abroad being taxed when giving up their citizenship. As far as I know, there is no European country that does anything remotely equivalent. I am willing to accept that there might be some, but this is far from the norm.

    Moving stuff across borders is something entirely different.