Comment by sixo

Comment by sixo 2 months ago

4 replies

Advice for anyone reading the Iliad: read Simone Weil's essay "The Iliad, or the Poem of Force" first [1]. The essay was a profound experience on its own for me, in a way that came as a great relief in a world which seemed to lack all moral gravity. (Note, it was written in 1945.)

And it conveys better than anything why the epic was composed, why it survived to be written down (the Bronze Age Collapse and a whole dark age separated the era of the Trojan War from the era of Homer!) and why people have been reading it for almost three thousand years.

[1] https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/simone-weil-the-ilia...

cafard 2 months ago

I found it interesting, but I think that Weil is trying to yoke together the Greek epics and Christianity, both of which were profoundly important to her, but which really aren't compatible at the level she wants.

NYRB brought out a small volume containing Weil's essay and also Rachel Bespaloff's essays on Homer. I think Bespaloff gives a better picture. And Herman Broch's afterword is worth reading.

creer 2 months ago

Thanks for the reference! For the original french, "L'Iliade ou le poème de la force" also readily available.

lukasb 2 months ago

Absolutely worth reading, even if you have no intention of reading Homer.

  • 082349872349872 2 months ago

    > ...failing everything else, there is always a god handy to advise him to be unreasonable.

    Even after a change of pantheon, the same pattern recurs: "Caedite eos. Novit enim Dominus qui sunt eius."

    > How soon this will happen is another question.

    On the greek calends?