Comment by ars

Comment by ars 3 days ago

15 replies

These pagers were distributed only to Hezbollah members, these were not just standard pagers anyone could buy.

NelsonMinar 3 days ago

Do you have a reference for that? And does it explain how Israel's assassins were sure none of the pagers weren't resold, nor given away, nor that someone's kid was playing with it?

seo-speedwagon 3 days ago

Hezbollah also has a massive social services wing, operating hospitals, schools, etc. I'd keep that in mind when hitching my wagon to this line of thinking.

  • ars 3 days ago

    Those people aren't getting a secure one-way pager giving them secret messages.

    They use a standard phone.

    • seo-speedwagon 3 days ago

      Nothing in the linked article backs up the implication that only members of Helbollah’s militant wing had these.

      It did, however, mention that an 8 year old girl was killed by one of them. Which is a foreseeable consequence of widely distributing a bunch of bombs and then detonating them without regard for who’s nearby.

    • wut42 3 days ago

      Some sources are saying that some medics have been victims. Pagers are apparently a very useful resource for emergencies/medics (see motorola website).

      The pagers were not secure at all also.

sureglymop 3 days ago

Even though I personally doubt this statement, care to explain how that would possibly be enough? If an explosion happens, everyone in range is hit.

  • s1artibartfast 3 days ago

    "Enough" to meet what criteria? A couple foot blast on handheld device on a military personnel is brain surgery in comparison to typical rockets with accuracy and blast radii measured in double digit meters

  • tptacek 3 days ago

    Hezbollah operates a parallel telecommunications network. They are not a terrorist group so much as the de facto government of Lebanon and a parallel armed forces. It is unlikely that anyone unaffiliated with Hezbollah could have used these pagers.

    • jknoepfler 3 days ago

      like I don't know, someone's spouse or child? Someone standing next to the thing when it's sitting on a night stand?

  • jandrewrogers 3 days ago

    Small charges (measured in grams) are extremely local and typically highly directional. They have a distinctive signature that is in evidence here. It isn't like a giant bomb going off.

  • yoavm 3 days ago

    With the size of these explosions, the "range" seems very small.

jknoepfler 3 days ago

you realize they exploded, right? potentially as someone's child was nearby. or playing with it. or in the middle of a grocery story.